From the BBC, via 3 Quarks Daily, a survey of British schoolchildren on their views about scientists.
The Science Learning Centre in London asked 11,000 pupils for their views on science and scientists. Around 70% of the 11-15 year olds questioned said they did not picture scientists as “normal young and attractive men and women”. The research examined why numbers of science exam entries are declining. They found around 80% of pupils thought scientists did “very important work” and 70% thought they worked “creatively and imaginatively”. Only 40% said they agreed that scientists did “boring and repetitive work”.
Over three quarters of the respondents thought scientists were “really brainy people”. The research is being undertaken as part of Einstein Year. Among those who said they would not like to be scientists, reasons included: “Because you would constantly be depressed and tired and not have time for family”, and “because they all wear big glasses and white coats and I am female”.
We obviously need to start posting more pictures of ourselves in our cool black leather lab coats. This white-lab-coat stereotype cannot stand.
Update: In the comments, Anna points to a fun site at Fermilab, describing the impressions that kids have of scientists both before and after visiting the lab. These drawings are by Amy.
The pictures are great, but the written descriptions are even better. Here is Beth, before::
The scientist has big square-shaped glasses and a big geeky nose with brown hair and blue eyes. I see a scientist working in a lab with a white lab coat . . . holding a beaker filled with solutions only he knows. Scientists are very interesting people who can figure out things we don’t even know exist.
And after visiting:
My picture of a scientist is completely different than what it used to be! The scientist I saw doesn’t wear a lab coat. . . . The scientists used good vocabulary and spoke like they knew what they were talking about.
Note “spoke like,” not simply “knew what they were talking about.” That Beth is a smart cookie.
Comments
28 responses to “You would constantly be depressed and tired”
I’ll also point out the value in breaking stereotypes. I was at the telescope for one run to get my thesis data and a group of tour guides in training came into the building. As it was only 1pm and I was unable to sleep, I was sitting in my PJ’s watching TV. I was asked about what I was observing and such when one older guy piped up with an embarrassed look. “So are you an astronomer?” he asked sheepishly. When I nodded, he continued, “I though they were… older.” I could also read in his face, “and male, and not prone to wearing blue striped flannel PJs.”
His face then lit up as he said, “I’m going to have to encourage my granddaughter more in her interest in science and astronomy.”
And this was already a guy interested in science and astronomy.
[…] Much has been said about the image that the public has about scientists – how we dress, how we work, what makes us laugh…In particular, one study concluded that children did not picture scientists as “normal young and attractive men and women.” Fermilab did their own study, asking 7th graders to draw pictures of scientists before and after visiting the laboratory – with markedly different images resulting from meeting real scientists at work. […]
[…] The popular public image of the scientist is a topic of understated importance in promoting scientific endeavors to funding agencies, encouraging young people to consider scientific careers, and to broaden the educational horizon of the lay person. There are many well-identified, detrimental stereotypes of scientists that the scientific community has made an effort to address. There are also a few well-identified, non-detrimental stereotypes that a few scientists seem to find amusing to hold on to… such as the image of a theoretical physicist wearing a labcoat. However, the stereotypes presented by ‘mad scientist’ figures in popular media are insidious and tend not to be addressed. Perhaps scientists think that comic book and television villains named Dr. Doom or Professor Chaos (ok, that one is a little whimsical) are so far removed from actual scientists that nobody could possibly get the subliminal hint that scientists are dangerous and not to be trusted? Well, kids spend far more time watching TV and reading comic books than visiting research labs. […]