Here’s how it starts. Click over to Abstruse Goose to see the exciting conclusion.
Message to science journalists: if this actually happened, it would be pretty awesome.
Here’s how it starts. Click over to Abstruse Goose to see the exciting conclusion.
Message to science journalists: if this actually happened, it would be pretty awesome.
Comments
24 responses to “Special Relativity, Simply Explained”
So, I’m working on this story about special relativity and I’d love to know if you have time for an interview… 😉
I have to come up with a good aliens-with-lasers thought experiment first.
I don’t know what’s the more outlandish part of that headline: “Respected scientist” or the “extraordinary claim”.
Wait, so you WANT to never again be taken seriously? I guess you can just trade APS conferences for Comic-Con.
[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Keith Soltys, Ron Simon and J.S., Cosmic Variance. Cosmic Variance said: Special Relativity, Simply Explained: Here’s how it starts. Click over to Abstruse Goose to see the exciting co… http://bit.ly/h1vtsr […]
Puahahahaha
hey Sean, didn’t this happened to you already?
And you shouldn’t miss this classic too : http://abstrusegoose.com/319
You do realise that’s the other dr Carroll, right?
Rupert and Roger make a killing on this, thus proving that News Corp can twist any fictitious story into a fact-based accounting, that at least one third of the population will believe.
I suppose this is better than Dr. Evil’s “sharks with frickin lasers”
I was quite amazed to find this statement in Conservapedia…
“Relativity has been met with much resistance in the scientific world.”
Such comments were expected regarding evolution and global warming, but relativity?!
Clear skies, Alan
Off topic, but I would dearly like to hear your comments about the significance of this article
http://arxiv.org/pdf/1011.3706v1
Clears it up for me. (Wow, aliens with lasers.)
Anyone who would think that they can explain special relativity to a newspaper reporter in 10 minutes is likely to get exactly what they deserve.
When your name shows up in xcdc is when you know you’ve made it in life.
Um, no frame of reference owns ultimate reality.
You folks snigger as if you do, and own SR too.
Snigger.
Funny you need it to be explained.
Snigger.
Just another thought experiment.
Snigger.
I’d never really realized that, since lasers propagate at the speed of light, they are a much better way of attacking distant star systems than almost any other weapon. We probably should be worried about this.
One potential problem with this thought experiment: If an alien member of a civilization advanced enough to send a spacecraft traveling at a significant fraction of the speed of light to our solar system to fire a laser directly at Earth exists, it may be indirect evidence that Special Relativity is wrong.
[…] Fri Nov 26th, 2010 by Sean | 91 commentsCosmic Variance | Special Relativity, Simply Explained […]
I find once you throw time skewing in, special relativity is pretty easy to get. Trouble is, length contraction and time dilation get all the glory.
Sadly, this kind of twisting of a scientific explanation, one that specifically uses a hypothetical, by the media is already happening. See, for example: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2010/12/coldest-winter-in-1000-years-cometh-–-not/
So, I guess I can’t really laugh at this cartoon.
This reminds me of a funny story: back when I was in graduate school, Joe Taylor won the Nobel Prize in physics, and journalists descended upon the department. So Taylor gave a press conference in the main auditorium, and a number of the graduate students attended as well.
Taylor explained in fairly simple terms the experimental observations, what it proved about general relativity, and so on. When he finished, one of the reporters asked, “Can you explain that again in laymen’s terms?” Taylor replied, “I thought I just did.”
The graduate students and professors laughed. The reporters, on the other hand, did not think that was funny at all. Which, of course, made it that much more hilarious.